HF4434

Requirements relating to design standards and variances in certain transportation projects modified, and report required.
Legislative Session 94 (2025-2026)

Related bill: SF4598

Bill text

Introduction

ReadChanges
PDF
(underlined = new law, struck through = current law the bill removes)
1.1A bill for an act
1.2relating to transportation; modifying requirements relating to design standards and
1.3variances in certain transportation projects; requiring a report; amending Minnesota
1.4Statutes 2024, sections 162.02, subdivision 3a, by adding subdivisions; 162.09,
1.5subdivision 3a, by adding subdivisions; 162.155; proposing coding for new law
1.6in Minnesota Statutes, chapter 162.
1.7BE IT ENACTED BY THE LEGISLATURE OF THE STATE OF MINNESOTA:
1.8Section 1. Minnesota Statutes 2024, section 162.02, is amended by adding a subdivision
1.9to read:
1.10 new text begin Subd. 1a. State-aid standards. Design and engineering standards for all new construction, new text end
1.11 new text begin reconstruction, rehabilitation, or resurfacing county state-aid projects approved by the new text end
1.12 new text begin state-aid engineer are determined and set by the most recent edition of the Facility Design new text end
1.13 new text begin Guide or successor document established by the commissioner. new text end
1.14 new text begin EFFECTIVE DATE. This section is effective July 1, 2026, for county state-aid roadway new text end
1.15 new text begin projects on or after that date. new text end
1.16Sec. 2. Minnesota Statutes 2024, section 162.02, subdivision 3a, is amended to read:
1.17Subd. 3a. Variances from rules and engineering standards. (a) The commissioner
1.18may grant variances from the rules and from the engineering standards developed pursuant
1.19to section 162.021 or 162.07, subdivision 2. A political subdivision in which a county
1.20state-aid highway is located or is proposed to be located may submit a written request to
1.21the commissioner for a variance for that highway. The commissioner deleted text begin shall deleted text end new text begin must new text end comply
1.22with section 174.75, subdivision 5, in evaluating a variance request related to a complete
1.23streets project.
2.1(b) The commissioner may grant or deny the variance within 30 days of receiving the
2.2variance request. If the variance is denied, the political subdivision may request, within 30
2.3days of receiving notice of denial, and deleted text begin shall deleted text end new text begin must new text end be granted a contested case hearing. new text begin The new text end
2.4 new text begin commissioner must use the criteria set forth in subdivision 3c to evaluate the variance new text end
2.5 new text begin request. new text end
2.6 new text begin (c) If the commissioner denies a variance, the commissioner must notify the chairs and new text end
2.7 new text begin ranking minority members of the legislative committees with jurisdiction over transportation new text end
2.8 new text begin and provide justification for denying the variance within 30 days of notifying the political new text end
2.9 new text begin subdivision of the denial. The justification must include the commissioner's reasoning for new text end
2.10 new text begin the denial, the recommendation of the advisory committee on variances, and the reasoning new text end
2.11 new text begin used by the committee to approve or deny the variance. new text end
2.12 deleted text begin (c) deleted text end new text begin (d) new text end For purposes of this subdivision, "political subdivision" includes (1) an agency
2.13of a political subdivision deleted text begin which deleted text end new text begin that new text end has jurisdiction over parks, and (2) a regional park
2.14authority.
2.15 new text begin (e) The commissioner must give special consideration to proposed modifications for: new text end
2.16 new text begin (1) narrowing lanes from 11 feet to ten feet for roadways in an urban or suburban context; new text end
2.17 new text begin (2) designs allowed by current Department of Transportation trunk highway standards new text end
2.18 new text begin for roadways of similar context; new text end
2.19 new text begin (3) a proposed design intended to increase the safety of nonmotorized transportation to new text end
2.20 new text begin and from a school; new text end
2.21 new text begin (4) a proposed design intended to increase the safety of nonmotorized access to a transit new text end
2.22 new text begin corridor; new text end
2.23 new text begin (5) any design element in a project funded by the safe routes to school program, except new text end
2.24 new text begin where specifically prohibited in the current Department of Transportation Facility Design new text end
2.25 new text begin Guide; or new text end
2.26 new text begin (6) a variance request that specifically states the proposed design modification is based new text end
2.27 new text begin on the following alternative design manuals: new text end
2.28 new text begin (i) the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials' (AASHTO) new text end
2.29 new text begin A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets or other AASHTO design guides new text end
2.30 new text begin formally recognized by the Federal Highway Administration; new text end
2.31 new text begin (ii) the Institute of Transportation Engineers' Designing Walkable Urban Thoroughfares: new text end
2.32 new text begin A Context Sensitive Approach and Implementing Context Sensitive Design Handbook; new text end
3.1 new text begin (iii) the National Association of City Transportation Officials' (NACTO) Urban Street new text end
3.2 new text begin Design Guide and other NACTO design guides formally recognized by the Federal Highway new text end
3.3 new text begin Administration; new text end
3.4 new text begin (iv) the Global Designing Cities Initiative's (GDCI) Global Street Design Guide and new text end
3.5 new text begin Designing Streets for Kids supplement; or new text end
3.6 new text begin (v) any other design guide recognized or approved by the Federal Highway new text end
3.7 new text begin Administration in United States Code, title 23, section 109(o)(B). new text end
3.8 new text begin (f) Paragraph (e) does not apply to a natural preservation route established under section new text end
3.9 new text begin 162.021. new text end
3.10 new text begin EFFECTIVE DATE. This section is effective July 1, 2026, for county state-aid roadway new text end
3.11 new text begin projects on or after that date. new text end
3.12Sec. 3. Minnesota Statutes 2024, section 162.02, is amended by adding a subdivision to
3.13read:
3.14 new text begin Subd. 3c. Variance format. To submit a formal request for a variance from applicable new text end
3.15 new text begin design standards under subdivision 1a, a political subdivision must submit a written request new text end
3.16 new text begin to the commissioner. The written request must be in the form of an adopted resolution. The new text end
3.17 new text begin request must: new text end
3.18 new text begin (1) identify the project by location and termini; new text end
3.19 new text begin (2) cite the specific part or standard for which the variance is requested from county new text end
3.20 new text begin state-aid design rules; new text end
3.21 new text begin (3) describe the proposed modification and include technical information about the new text end
3.22 new text begin design, including: new text end
3.23 new text begin (i) an index map; and new text end
3.24 new text begin (ii) a typical section with an inplace section and a proposed section; new text end
3.25 new text begin (4) describe the economic, social, safety, and environmental impacts that may result new text end
3.26 new text begin from the requested variance; new text end
3.27 new text begin (5) identify the project's effectiveness in eliminating an existing and projected deficiency new text end
3.28 new text begin in the transportation system, including identifying and citing whether the existing roadway's new text end
3.29 new text begin design meets a recognized or approved Federal Highway Administration design guide new text end
3.30 new text begin standard for a similar road context; new text end
3.31 new text begin (6) identify effects on adjacent lands; new text end
4.1 new text begin (7) identify the number of persons affected; and new text end
4.2 new text begin (8) identify relevant safety considerations as they apply to: new text end
4.3 new text begin (i) pedestrians; new text end
4.4 new text begin (ii) bicyclists; new text end
4.5 new text begin (iii) vulnerable road users; new text end
4.6 new text begin (iv) the motoring public; and new text end
4.7 new text begin (v) fire, police, and emergency service providers. new text end
4.8 new text begin EFFECTIVE DATE. This section is effective July 1, 2026, for county state-aid roadway new text end
4.9 new text begin projects on or after that date. new text end
4.10Sec. 4. Minnesota Statutes 2024, section 162.09, is amended by adding a subdivision to
4.11read:
4.12 new text begin Subd. 1a. State-aid standards. Design and engineering standards for all new construction, new text end
4.13 new text begin reconstruction, rehabilitation, or resurfacing municipal state-aid projects approved by the new text end
4.14 new text begin state-aid engineer are determined and set by the most recent edition of the Facility Design new text end
4.15 new text begin Guide or successor document established by the commissioner. new text end
4.16 new text begin EFFECTIVE DATE. This section is effective July 1, 2026, for municipal state-aid new text end
4.17 new text begin roadway projects on or after that date. new text end
4.18Sec. 5. Minnesota Statutes 2024, section 162.09, subdivision 3a, is amended to read:
4.19Subd. 3a. Variances from rules and engineering standards. (a) The commissioner
4.20may grant variances from the rules and from the engineering standards developed pursuant
4.21to section 162.13, subdivision 2. A political subdivision in which a municipal state-aid street
4.22is located or is proposed to be located may submit a written request to the commissioner
4.23for a variance for that street. The commissioner deleted text begin shall deleted text end new text begin must new text end comply with section 174.75,
4.24subdivision 5, in evaluating a variance request related to a complete streets project.
4.25(b) The commissioner may grant or deny the variance within 30 days of receiving the
4.26variance request. If the variance is denied, the political subdivision may request, within 30
4.27days of receiving notice of denial, and deleted text begin shall deleted text end new text begin must new text end be granted a contested case hearing. new text begin The new text end
4.28 new text begin commissioner must use the criteria set forth in subdivision 3b to evaluate the variance new text end
4.29 new text begin request. new text end
5.1 new text begin (c) If the commissioner denies a variance, the commissioner must notify the chairs and new text end
5.2 new text begin ranking minority members of the legislative committees with jurisdiction over transportation new text end
5.3 new text begin and provide justification for denying the variance within 30 days of notifying the political new text end
5.4 new text begin subdivision of the denial. The justification must include the commissioner's reasoning for new text end
5.5 new text begin the denial, the recommendation of the advisory committee on variances, and the reasoning new text end
5.6 new text begin used by the committee to approve or deny the variance. new text end
5.7 deleted text begin (c) deleted text end new text begin (d) new text end For purposes of this subdivision, "political subdivision" includes (1) an agency
5.8of a political subdivision deleted text begin which deleted text end new text begin that new text end has jurisdiction over parks, and (2) a regional park
5.9authority.
5.10 new text begin (e) The commissioner must give special consideration to proposed modifications for: new text end
5.11 new text begin (1) narrowing lanes from 11 feet to ten feet for roadways in an urban or suburban context; new text end
5.12 new text begin (2) designs allowed by current Department of Transportation trunk highway standards new text end
5.13 new text begin for roadways of similar context; new text end
5.14 new text begin (3) a proposed design intended to increase the safety of nonmotorized transportation to new text end
5.15 new text begin and from a school; new text end
5.16 new text begin (4) any design element in a project funded by the safe routes to school program, except new text end
5.17 new text begin where specifically prohibited in the current Department of Transportation Facility Design new text end
5.18 new text begin Guide; or new text end
5.19 new text begin (5) a variance request that specifically states the proposed design modification is based new text end
5.20 new text begin on the following alternative design manuals: new text end
5.21 new text begin (i) the American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials' (AASHTO) new text end
5.22 new text begin A Policy on Geometric Design of Highways and Streets or other AASHTO design guides new text end
5.23 new text begin formally recognized by the Federal Highway Administration; new text end
5.24 new text begin (ii) the Institute of Transportation Engineers' Designing Walkable Urban Thoroughfares: new text end
5.25 new text begin A Context Sensitive Approach and Implementing Context Sensitive Design Handbook; new text end
5.26 new text begin (iii) the National Association of City Transportation Officials' (NACTO) Urban Street new text end
5.27 new text begin Design Guide and other NACTO design guides formally recognized by the Federal Highway new text end
5.28 new text begin Administration; new text end
5.29 new text begin (iv) the Global Designing Cities Initiative's (GDCI) Global Street Design Guide and new text end
5.30 new text begin Designing Streets for Kids supplement; or new text end
5.31 new text begin (v) any other design guide recognized or approved by the Federal Highway new text end
5.32 new text begin Administration in United States Code, title 23, section 109(o)(B). new text end
6.1 new text begin EFFECTIVE DATE. This section is effective July 1, 2026, for municipal state-aid new text end
6.2 new text begin roadway projects on or after that date. new text end
6.3Sec. 6. Minnesota Statutes 2024, section 162.09, is amended by adding a subdivision to
6.4read:
6.5 new text begin Subd. 3b. Variance format. To submit a formal request for a variance from municipal new text end
6.6 new text begin state-aid design rules, a political subdivision must submit a written request to the new text end
6.7 new text begin commissioner. The written request must be in the form of an adopted resolution. The request new text end
6.8 new text begin must: new text end
6.9 new text begin (1) identify the project by location and termini; new text end
6.10 new text begin (2) cite the specific part or standard for which the variance is requested from municipal new text end
6.11 new text begin state-aid design rules; new text end
6.12 new text begin (3) describe the proposed modification and include technical information about the new text end
6.13 new text begin design, including: new text end
6.14 new text begin (i) an index map; and new text end
6.15 new text begin (ii) a typical section with an inplace section and a proposed section; new text end
6.16 new text begin (4) describe the economic, social, safety, and environmental impacts that may result new text end
6.17 new text begin from the requested variance; new text end
6.18 new text begin (5) identify the effectiveness of the project in eliminating an existing and projected new text end
6.19 new text begin deficiency in the transportation system, including identifying and citing whether the existing new text end
6.20 new text begin roadway's design meets a recognized or approved Federal Highway Administration design new text end
6.21 new text begin guide standard for a similar road context; new text end
6.22 new text begin (6) identify effects on adjacent lands; new text end
6.23 new text begin (7) identify the number of persons affected; and new text end
6.24 new text begin (8) identify relevant safety considerations as they apply to: new text end
6.25 new text begin (i) pedestrians; new text end
6.26 new text begin (ii) bicyclists; new text end
6.27 new text begin (iii) vulnerable road users; new text end
6.28 new text begin (iv) the motoring public; and new text end
6.29 new text begin (v) fire, police, and emergency service providers. new text end
7.1 new text begin EFFECTIVE DATE. This section is effective July 1, 2026, for municipal state-aid new text end
7.2 new text begin roadway projects on or after that date. new text end
7.3Sec. 7. new text begin [162.095] ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON DESIGN VARIANCES. new text end
7.4 new text begin Subdivision 1. Establishment. An advisory committee on design variances is established new text end
7.5 new text begin to investigate and determine a recommendation for each variance submitted under sections new text end
7.6 new text begin 162.02, subdivision 3a, and 162.09, subdivision 3a. new text end
7.7 new text begin Subd. 2. Membership. (a) The advisory committee on design variances called by the new text end
7.8 new text begin commissioner under subdivision 3 must consist of the following members: new text end
7.9 new text begin (1) not more than two county highway engineers, only one of whom may be from a new text end
7.10 new text begin county containing a city of the first class; new text end
7.11 new text begin (2) not more than two city engineers, only one of whom may be from a city of the first new text end
7.12 new text begin class; new text end
7.13 new text begin (3) not more than two county officials, only one of whom may be from a county new text end
7.14 new text begin containing a city of the first class; new text end
7.15 new text begin (4) not more than two officials of an urban municipality, only one of whom may be from new text end
7.16 new text begin a city of the first class; new text end
7.17 new text begin (5) not more than two representatives of the Office of Transit and Active Transportation new text end
7.18 new text begin in the Department of Transportation, one of whom must be an engineer; and new text end
7.19 new text begin (6) one representative from the State Aid for Local Transportation Office in the new text end
7.20 new text begin Department of Transportation with experience in project design and the safety factors new text end
7.21 new text begin specified in sections 162.02, subdivision 3c, and 162.09, subdivision 3b. new text end
7.22 new text begin (b) No elected or appointed official that represents a political subdivision may serve on new text end
7.23 new text begin the committee. new text end
7.24 new text begin (c) The committee must have at least one member but not more than 12 members from new text end
7.25 new text begin a metropolitan area as defined in section 473.121, subdivision 2, as well as cities with a new text end
7.26 new text begin population over 50,000 according to the most recent federal census. new text end
7.27 new text begin Subd. 3. Operating procedure; open meeting law. (a) The advisory committee must new text end
7.28 new text begin meet at the call of the commissioner, at which time the committee must be instructed as to new text end
7.29 new text begin the committee's responsibilities by a designee of the commissioner. The members of the new text end
7.30 new text begin advisory committee must elect a chair from the members of the group at the initial meeting new text end
7.31 new text begin and may set bylaws and procedures to investigate the requested variance. new text end
8.1 new text begin (b) An advisory committee organized under this section is subject to the Minnesota Open new text end
8.2 new text begin Meeting Law under chapter 13D. new text end
8.3 new text begin Subd. 4. Factors considered. The advisory committee must make a recommendation new text end
8.4 new text begin for a variance based on criteria set forth in sections 162.02, subdivision 3c, and 162.09, new text end
8.5 new text begin subdivision 3b. The advisory committee must give special consideration to safety if the new text end
8.6 new text begin proposed project design is intended to increase the safety of nonmotorized transportation new text end
8.7 new text begin to and from a school. new text end
8.8 new text begin Subd. 5. Recommendation. After considering all data pertinent to the requested variance, new text end
8.9 new text begin the advisory committee must recommend to the commissioner approval or denial of the new text end
8.10 new text begin request. If the committee denies the variance, the committee must provide specific reasoning new text end
8.11 new text begin for the denial and identify the design standard used to evaluate the denial. new text end
8.12 new text begin Subd. 6. Administration. Upon request of the advisory committee, the commissioner new text end
8.13 new text begin must provide meeting space, technical support, and administrative services for the group. new text end
8.14 new text begin Subd. 7. Legislative report. By January 15 of each even-numbered year, the new text end
8.15 new text begin commissioner of transportation must submit a report to the chairs and ranking minority new text end
8.16 new text begin members of the legislative committees with jurisdiction over transportation policy and new text end
8.17 new text begin finance. The report must summarize the activities of any advisory committee on variances new text end
8.18 new text begin from the prior two years, identify each committee's analysis and findings for each variance new text end
8.19 new text begin approved or denied, identify whether the commissioner and an advisory committee came new text end
8.20 new text begin to a different decision on a requested variance and identify the reasons for the difference, new text end
8.21 new text begin and provide recommendations on improvements to the advisory committee process. new text end
8.22 new text begin EFFECTIVE DATE. This section is effective July 1, 2026, for state-aid design variances new text end
8.23 new text begin sought on or after that date. new text end
8.24Sec. 8. Minnesota Statutes 2024, section 162.155, is amended to read:
8.25162.155 RULEMAKING.
8.26 deleted text begin (a) The commissioner shall adopt rules setting forth the criteria to be considered by the deleted text end
8.27 deleted text begin commissioner in evaluating requests for variances under sections 162.02, subdivision 3a deleted text end
8.28 deleted text begin and 162.09, subdivision 3a. The rules must include, but are not limited to, economic, deleted text end
8.29 deleted text begin engineering and safety guidelines. deleted text end
8.30 deleted text begin (b) deleted text end new text begin (a) new text end The commissioner shall adopt rules establishing the engineering standards for
8.31cost estimation under sections 162.07, subdivision 2, and 162.13, subdivision 2.
9.1 deleted text begin (c) deleted text end new text begin (b) new text end The rules adopted by the commissioner under this section, and sections 162.02;
9.2162.07, subdivision 2; 162.09; and 162.13, subdivision 2, are exempt from the rulemaking
9.3provisions of chapter 14. The rules are subject to section 14.386, except that, notwithstanding
9.4paragraph (b) of that section, the rules continue in effect until repealed or superseded by
9.5other law or rule.

Bill information comes from public records published by the Office of the Revisor of Statutes, the Minnesota House and the Minnesota Senate. AI summaries are written by MinneSlate and are not official. MinneSlate is independent and is not affiliated with the State of Minnesota or the Minnesota Legislature.

Progress through the legislative process

17%
In Committee
Loading…